Too busy to bake for your mom this Mother’s Day?
We understand. Many pull out the baking mitts when the holidays roll around, but if you’re not blessed with culinary skills (or time), there are more than a few best cookie delivery services to order from.
Here at Post Wanted, we’re deep into gift guides and holiday planning. Naturally, none of us have time to be in our kitchens. And while we can’t prove it, we’re sure that more than a few of you can relate.
- Best overall: Brooklyn Blackout Cookie
- Best Thick Cookies: Levain Bakery
- Best Classic Cookies: Jacques Torres Chocolate
- Best for Creative Flavors: Milk Bar
- Best Frosted: Cheryl’s
- Best for Classic Flavors: David’s Cookies
- Best for Cookie Cakes: Mrs. Fields
Having a tin of cookies delivered straight you your mom’s door ahead of May 11 (mark your calendars, people), is certainly a sweet surprise. But, cookie delivery is also a great idea for any far-away family members, like your kids’ teachers, work pals, and anyone else you know who needs a pick-me-up, sweet tooth style!
We’ve found cookie companies sure to suit every type of taste and diet — from the NYC favorites Levain and Brooklyn Blackout Cookie, plus many more options from Goldbelly. Of course, we also had to put a few of the hottest bakeries to the test, by sampling some best-sellers ourselves.
Whether your intended receiver is vegan, gluten-free, or a true chocoholic, there’s a cookie for them! Here are our favorite places to order this iconic dessert.
Best Cookie Delivery Services
Best overall: Brooklyn Blackout Cookie
Pros:
- Rich, decadent, chocolate drizzle over the cookies
- Soft, gooey, and easy to chew
- The perfect size that leaves you wanting more
- Tasted super fresh even though they were not individually wrapped
Cons:
- Chocolate flavors could be overpowering for some
- Durable tin packaging, but not individually wrapped
Made in Brooklyn with love, the Blackout Cookies ($65) do not mess around. Inspired by the historic Brooklyn Blackout Cake that exploded in popularity during World War II, the modern bite-sized version shares the same swirling chocolate flavor and rich coating that has the power to blast anyone out of a dark depression. We tested them ourselves and concluded that they could even convert non-chocolate lovers.
New York Post: “In the brilliant words of New York Post restaurant critic Steve Cuozzo, ‘Brooklyn does it better.’ When it comes to Blackout Cookies, we have to agree. Filled with rich flavors, the perfect amount of chips, and dunked in a layer of soft chocolate, these are not just cookies. The size is just right, not too big, not too small, but definitely leaving you wanting more. In fact, we all needed seconds, and some of us — thirds. Our Editorial Director declared these a true dessert.”
Shipping: If you are placing an order for a time-sensitive event, Goldbelly recommends placing your order early and scheduling it to arrive two or more days before your event. All packages are shipped via UPS or FedEx and therefore cannot be shipped to P.O. Box addresses.
Best Thick Cookies: Levain Bakery
Pros:
- Wide selection of flavors
- Various sized bundles
- Affordable options available
Cons:
- On the thicker side and I can be a bit harder to hold and bite — personal preference
As one of New York City’s finest, we couldn’t refrain from placing Levain near the top of this list. The bakery’s extravagant Cookie Tins ($65) offers a treat that family, friends, or even the office can share. Plus, they’re completely customizable, so you can choose all your favorite flavors, from Oatmeal Raisin and Caramel Coconut Chocolate Chip to Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter and more cult favorites.
New York Post Review: “Oh Levain, you are so well-loved by us New Yorkers that for most of us Posties, this was not our first bite. These cookies are not just thick; they are monstrous. It was almost overwhelmingly flavorful, which we actually agreed was a good thing. They will fill you up fast, that’s for sure. Sweet? Yes. But not so sweet that they’re headache-inducing. Among all we tested, the chocolate peanut butter flavor received the most “ooohs” and “awws.” It had that nostalgic Smuckers-like flavor that makes you remember what a good cookie should taste like. Levain doesn’t mess around with presentation either, the tin is so well put together that it would make a lovely gift if you can resist snagging them for yourself.”
Shipping: One and two-day ground shipping cost is $12.50, two-day air shipping cost is $20, and overnight air shipping cost is $49.
Best Classic Cookies: Jacques Torres Chocolate
Pros:
- Just the right texture, per our testing
- Tastes like a classic, homemade cookie
- Not too sweet, just right
- Oversized is ideal for sharing
Cons:
- The packaging was a bit flimsy, but the round design is unique
Jacques Torres Chocolate may be better known for its world-famous chocolate truffles creations, but the Chocolate Chip Cookies ($50) are not to be missed. These classic cookies have a buttery flavor and traditional look, which makes them a safe bet to send to just about anyone in need of a sweet treat. They’re pretty oversized too, so they might not mind sharing.
New York Post Review: “Sure, Jacques Torres Chocolate may not be the first company that comes to mind when you think of where to order cookies from. However, these giant chocolate chip cookies taste like they came straight out of your Grandma’s oven. They’re fresh, buttery, and have just the right texture — soft on the inside, crispy on the outside. Perfectly indulgent. We only wish Jacques would come out with some new flavors for us to try.”
Shipping: If you are placing an order for a time-sensitive event, Goldbelly recommends placing your order early and scheduling it to arrive two or more days before your event. All packages are shipped via UPS or FedEx and therefore cannot be shipped to P.O. Box addresses.
Best Nut Cookies: Maman
Pros:
- Decadent gooey-on-the-inside texture
- Not overly sweet, per testing
- A delicious combination of flavors with bittersweet chocolate and mixed nuts
- Beautiful packaging
Cons:
- On the thicker side and I can be a bit harder to hold and bite — personal preference
Oprah’s favorite Nutty Cookies ($80)? Count us in. These nut-heavy chocolate chip cookies are celebrity-approved and taste as good as they look. Naturally, we had to try them ourselves. If just judged on presentation alone, we’d have to give them five stars. The classic blue-and-white box is so charming that we want to keep it for future gift wrapping.
New York Post Review: “The French do everything better, chocolate chip cookies included. There is something so distinctly Maman about these hunky, gooey-on-the-inside cookies that I could easily identify them in a blind taste test. Not overly sugary, the combination of bittersweet chocolate chunks, walnuts, almonds, and macadamia nuts makes every bite feel like an adventure. When they say they’re crave-worthy, they’re not lying.”
Shipping: If you are placing an order for a time-sensitive event, Goldbelly recommends placing your order early and scheduling it to arrive two or more days before your event. All packages are shipped via UPS or FedEx and therefore cannot be shipped to P.O. Box addresses.
Best Vegan and Gluten-Free Cookies: Ovenly
Pros:
- Overly offers a range of gluten-free and vegan options in creative flavors
- Durable packaging in a cardboard box
Cons:
- A bit salty and drier than we liked, per testing
Vegan cookies are hard to come by and hard to perfect, but Ovenly has come up with a range of dietary-friendly options that are good-looking and still palatable. The packaging is durable, and each cookie is individually wrapped to maintain optimal freshness. We put the Gluten-Free Salted Peanut Butter ($50) and Secrety Vegan ($46) flavors to the test.
New York Post Review: “Full transparency: These were not our favorite cookies, but we understand that making gluten-free and vegan cookies taste like normal cookies is a near-impossible feat. Considering that these are missing some of our favorite ingredients (AKA flour and milk), they still tasted pretty good. But, secretly vegan? Not so much. They’re a little sweet and a touch salty, which creates an unusual flavor pairing that sets them apart from some other options. While the vegan cookie was on the drier side, the gluten-free peanut butter cookie was actually the perfect amount of melty and gooey. On a more health-conscious day, I might pick it out over a gluten-full option.”
Shipping: If you are placing an order for a time-sensitive event, Goldbelly recommends placing your order early and scheduling it to arrive two or more days before your event. All packages are shipped via UPS or FedEx and therefore cannot be shipped to P.O. Box addresses.
Best Variety: Chip City Cookies
Pros:
- Directions for reheating included
- A wide variety of creative flavors like confetti and cookies and cream
- Separators to keep the cookies organized
Cons:
- A little on the drier side
Coming out of Astoria, Queens, Chip City Cookies is one of the fastest-growing cookie bakeries on the East Coast. If you’re after creative flavors, this is the place to go. Filled with fun, nostalgic flavors like Confetti, Campfire, and Cookie Dough — Chip City has no shortage of options.
New York Post Review: “For those who desire something dense with a bit of crunch, Chip City hits the ball out of the park. They’re large and filling, and the edges are just a touch crispy. We also have to give praise for the flavor variety and originality. The Jumbo Cookie Sampler ($50) gave us a taste of some best-sellers, and if you have a sweet tooth these will satisfy it. The box recommends using the microwave or oven to reheat them, and we think they’d have tasted even better had we been able to follow those directions. Extra points for phenomenal packaging, the individual dividers keep this cookie box neat and organized.”
Shipping: If you are placing an order for a time-sensitive event, Goldbelly recommends placing your order early and scheduling it to arrive two or more days before your event. All packages are shipped via UPS or FedEx and therefore cannot be shipped to P.O. Box addresses.
Best Splurge Cookie: Last Crumb
Pros:
- Decadent and rich flavors
- Two-week shelf
Cons:
- More expensive
Ready to try the gold standard in cookies? Last Crumb may be the last cookie company you ever taste — because this brand is so good, you won’t want to go back to those stale, store-bought cookies. They may be on the pricey side, but the presentation and flavor variety are top-notch.
For a special occasion, we suggest you try The Core Collection ($120), which features best-selling flavors like Oreo Milkshake, Blueberry Muffin, Chocolate Lava, and Lemon Bar. With a two-week shelf life, you should have some time to enjoy them.
Shipping: Standard shipping typically takes 1-2 business days and overnight shipping is unmistakably… overnight.
Best for Creative Flavors: Milk Bar
Pros:
- Wide selection of desserts
- Fun and memorable flavors, such as Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, and Blueberry Cream
- Options for those who are gluten-free
Cons:
- We love this cookie delivery service but accept that those with less adventurous tastebuds may not be impressed
Milk Bar has been “shaking up the dessert scene” for more than a decade with its sweet orders of cakes, pies, and cookies. It’s really the delivery to know if you’re seeking desserts with that ‘whoa-factor,’ as options are not only aesthetically pleasing but absolutely delicious. If you prefer your cookies soft on the inside and crispy on the outside, Milk Bar is for you!
The site is stocked with limited-time delicacies, but the classics are arguably just as good. Consider bundling up with The Cookie Faves Tin ($46) to try out the popular Cornflake Chocolate Chip and Compost Cookies. Don’t let the names fool you — cookie lovers swear these are some of the best.
Shipping: Milk Bar offers nationwide shipping and on-demand local delivery. Most packages are delivered within one to two days.
Best Cooking Bundles: David’s Cookies
Pros:
- Cookies come in adorable, very giftable tins
- Also has birthday cakes, cheesecakes, and dietary-friendly dessert options
- Wide range of flavors
Cons:
- Expedited shipping is a bit pricey
If you’re a fan of QVC, you’ve likely heard of David’s Cookies once or twice. Best known for its cookie bundles, you can take a bite out of its Fresh-baked Assorted Cookies Tin ($33), Signature Cookie Brownie Assortment ($43), Fresh Baked Decadent Jumbo 2lb Tin of S’Mores Cookies ($40), among plenty of others.
David’s cookies have ramped up their selection of gift boxes and cookie tins. You’ll find everything from the I Love You Butter Pecan Meltaways ($34) to the Gluten-Free I Love You Cookie and Brownie Bucket ($40), which satisfies everyone’s needs — including those with dietary restrictions.
Shipping: Standard delivery is a two-day service via UPS at $6.95. Expedited is $39.95.
Best Frosted: Cheryl’s
Pros:
- Same day delivery
- Lots of options for the holidays
- Sugar-free, kosher, and gluten-free options
Cons:
- A huge selection can be overwhelming to navigate
Cheryl’s is the quintessential cookie gift-and-send service that freshly bakes items like the Cheryl’s Dessert Tray Gift Box ($100), Gourmet Unfrosted batch ($30+), and even Cookie Dough and Decorating Kits ($25). That’s right, they have ready-to-eat cookie dough gift sets in a variety of flavors, from chocolate chip to peanut butter truffle.
Shipping: If you would like your gift to arrive on a particular day, Cheryl’s recommends an Overnight Shipping service to guarantee your delivery.
Best for Cookie Cakes: Mrs. Fields
Pros:
- Great gifting options
- Cookies are ultra chewy and moist
- A recognizable brand that most people (and palettes) love
Cons:
- Recipes are on the traditional side, so if you like more unique flavors, we suggest checking some of the other cookie delivery services on our list
All hail the queen of chocolate chip: Mrs. Fields. Whether you’re eyeing the chunky classic desserts from inside your shopping mall or scrolling through all its festive and traditional packages online, you can’t go wrong with gifting from this classic concierge.
The iconic brand has a massive selection of goodies, with plenty of options for the upcoming holidays, including Mother’s Day. Mrs. Field also has options for customization and delicious Cookie Cakes under $50 for those looking to save some money.
Shipping: The ground delivery date is not guaranteed; the package can be delivered within one to two business days before or after your selected delivery date.
Best Presentation: Harry & David
Pros:
- The baskets that the cookies come in are gorgeous, making them a great gift option for the holidays
- Wide selection of cookies, as well as fruit, and savory baskets
- Good for those looking for something impressive but also budget-friendly
Cons:
- Cookies tend to be on the crispier/crunchy side
Harry & David has so many options, you’re sure to find something fantastic tasting for whomever you’re shopping for. We love the Deluxe Signature Cookie Basket ($50), which comes with a fruit-heavy variety, including Blackberry Galettes, White Chocolate Rasberry, Lemon Citrus, and a whole lot more.
Or, for those who prefer a more buttery cookie, there’s the Fruit Galette Tin ($35), which brims with delicious galettes crafted with real butter and decadent jam.Harry & David also has lots of savory gift baskets and fruit baskets, too!
Shipping: Standard Shipping charges are applied. Standard rates are based on the non-sale price, as detailed in the charts here.
Best Desserts: Magnolia Bakery
Pros:
- Variety of different treats — not just cookies
- DoorDash exclusive bread pudding
Cons:
- Not a great option for those who are gluten-free
Yes, Magnolia Bakery does more than cupcakes and bread pudding! The iconic bakery, based in New York City, also makes delicious cookies that can be delivered straight to the door of someone you love. Check out the Brownie and Blondie Combo ($34) and Banana Pudding Lovers Sampler Pack ($84) for some inspiration.
We recommend scoping out the selection of sample packs. From Banana Bread Cookies ($28) to soft and chewy Chocolate Chunk ($21), there’s a flavor waiting to be enjoyed with a warm cup of milk, cocoa, or whatever you like pairing with the dessert.
Shipping: Magnolia Bakery offers nationwide shipping on select products in the Magnolia Bakery Online Store. You can make and schedule orders for same-day pick-up or delivery using the Doordash partner portals.
Best Assortment: 1-800 Flowers
Pros:
- Specialty baskets, including cakes and cookies, fruit, and flowers
- A variety of flavors, ranging from unique to classic
- Same delivery in select locations
Cons:
- None to speak of
1-800 Flowers may be your go-to service for an apology bouquet or last-minute present, but the quick gift delivery service also offers a wide variety of cookies. We suggest you browse the treat tins if you’re gifting a larger party. There are many options that can feed upwards of eight hungry mouths. The pink and white LoveShackFancy Love in Bloom Cookies ($30) might be our favorite option ahead of Spring.
If you’re interested in trying a spin on classic cookies, 1-800 Flowers also has cakes, pies, and — wait for it — ice cream! It’s truly a one-stop shop when dessert is concerned, especially if you’re looking to send something sweet to someone you love.
Shipping: International delivery to 195 countries worldwide. Direct Ship items are only available for delivery in the continental United States. Delivers through FedEx, UPS, and United States Postal Service.
Best for Sweet Treats: Dylan’s Candy Bar
Pros:
- Unique collaborations, including a recent LOVESHACKFANCY candy collection
- Elegantly wrapped, bright, vibrant colors
- Houses over 7,000 different confections
Cons:
- More sweets to choose from, but fewer traditional cookie options
Prepare to meet your inner child. Dylan’s Candy Bar houses over 7,000 delightful confections, which means there is basically a sweet treat for everyone — a sea of cookies included. The bold and bright presentation makes it difficult to imagine eating some of these delicacies (how could you smash into the Surprise Bash Heart?), but reviewers agree they taste as good as they look.
If you’re hunting for the perfect gift for a kiddo, we suggest the Chocolate-Covered Animal Cracker Gift Box ($24). This nostalgic treat even gives back — a portion of the proceeds are donated to help animals in need. We’re also eyeing the Anniversary Foiled Chocolate-Covered Cookies ($35), curated to replicate the stores’ iconic, colorful lollipop trees.
Shipping: All orders have a standard processing time of at least 1-2 business days. This includes orders that are shipped UPS 2nd Day and Next Day Air.
Best Gourmet: Gourmet Gift Baskets
Pros:
- Cookie baskets, as well as savory options
- Beautiful packaging for holiday gifting
- Easy to navigate site
Cons:
- Baskets are slightly pricier but they’re also very large, which explains the cost
If you’re looking for a simple, straightforward, and elegantly wrapped gift box full of assorted cookies, then stop in your tracks and head to Gourmetgiftbaskets.com. We love the brand for gifting something thoughtful to coworkers, our kids’ teachers, and neighbors. Everything comes in such beautiful packaging, and the options available are endless.
If you’re looking for something that has a bit of everything, we recommend the Sweets and Treats Gift Basket ($40), which comes with an assortment of brownies and cookies for every taste. The With Love Cookie & Brownie Gift Box ($40) is another popular pick.
Shipping: Shipments are guaranteed for Ground, Three-Day, Two-Day, Overnight, and Saturday. Gourmet Gift Baskets run over 99% on time so trouble with shipping is a very infrequent event.
FAQs
Who has the best online cookies?
Cookies are sort of like clothes. What’s best all depends on your personal taste and needs. Do you like a moist, chewy cookie or something crispy around the edges? Whatever your answer, you’ll get no judgments from us. We love cookies and will take them however we can.
When it comes to online cookie shopping, a handful of options ship nationally. Here are a few favorites:
What is the cheapest way to ship cookies?
For free, of course!
Although shipping costs vary depending on the cookie delivery service you go with, some do offer shipping at no cost at certain times throughout the year. Cheryl’s Passport Membership ($30, $20 per year), also affiliated with Harry & David’s Passport Membership ($29.99 per year), earns customers lots of perks, like bonus points, early access to products and — you guessed it — your order, free. It’s definitely worth checking out, especially if you find yourself sending different gift baskets throughout the year.
How We Tested
Everyone has a unique taste for sweets, so we enlisted the help of a few Post Wanted team members to put these cookies to the ultimate taste test — Cookiepalooza. We evaluated each on four different factors: Packaging, freshness, flavor, and texture.
- Freshness: While evaluating freshness, we checked to see whether each cookie was individually wrapped to preserve its quality. We also took notes on how fresh they tasted and felt and whether there was any crumbling as we took them out of the bags.
- Flavor: Flavor is subjective, but we did consider a few different factors, including the sweetness level, the quality of the ingredients, and whether there were any unique flavor options that made the brand stand out. If any ingredient tasted overpowering, we made note of it.
- Packaging: Packing is very important when it comes to cookie delivery, as some cookies have a short shelf-life. We evaluated the durability of the cookie boxes and tins, as well as the aesthetics/design of the packaging. Extra consideration was given to cookies with directions for reheating and flavor guides.
- Texture: Some people like their cookies soft, others chewy, and some crunchy. We looked for cookies that followed the traditional crispy-outside, gooey-inside texture, which also seems to correspond with freshness.
Hunting for a headline-worthy haul? Keep shopping with Post Wanted.
Why Trust Post Wanted by the New York Post
For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.